THE CHANGING LAW OF THE EMPLOYMENT RELATIONSHIP This page intentionally left blank The Changing Law of the Employment Relationship Comparative Analyses in the European Context NICOLA COUNTOURIS University of Reading, UK © Nicola Countouris 2007 All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior permission of the publisher Nicola Countouris has asserted his moral right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as the author of this work Published by Ashgate Publishing Limited Gower House Croft Road Aldershot Hampshire GU11 3HR England Ashgate Publishing Company Suite 420 101 Cherry Street Burlington, VT 05401-4405 USA Ashgate website: http://www.ashgate.com British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Countouris, Nicola, 1975The changing law of the employment relationship: comparative analyses in the European context Labor laws and legislation - Europe I Title 344.4'01 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Countouris, Nicola, 1975The changing law of the employment relationship : comparative analyses in the European context / by Nicola Countouris p cm (Studies in modern law and policy series) Includes bibliographical references and index ISBN 978-0-7546-4800-0 Labor laws and legislation Europe Personnel management Europe I Title KJC2855.C68 2007 344.401 dc22 2007009692 ISBN 978-0-7546-4800-0 Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire Contents Table of Cases Table of Legislation Preface List of Abbreviations vii xi xix xxi Introduction The aims of the book Scope and methodology Structure and summary of the book 1 12 The Employment Relationship and the Contract of Employment in Industrialised Societies Introduction The industrial revolution and the birth of the contract of employment The unitary notion of contract of employment The breakdown of the employment relationship The contractual dimensions of the employment relationship Conclusions Reshaping the Personal Scope of LabourLaw: An Analysis of Current Debates in Europe Introduction Stretching the notion of ‘employee’ The debate over the ‘grey zone’ between employment and self-employment Re-targeting labour law Conclusions Atypical Employment Relationships: A Comparative Analysis of Fixed-term, Part-time and Temporary Agency Work in Europe Introduction Early legislation and the status of atypical workers Regulation and unemployment: typical rights for atypical workers Flexibility and special rights for ‘more and better’ atypical jobs in the 1990s: from social stability to social acceptance and normalisation? Conclusions 15 15 16 25 40 53 55 57 57 58 71 81 83 87 87 89 105 121 141 The Changing Law of the Employment Relationship vi The ILO Notion of the Worker and the Scope of the Employment Relationship Introduction The personal scope of application of ILO instruments The ILO regulatory instruments on atypical work The ILO initiative on the scope of the employment relationship Conclusions The Personal Scope of Application of EC Social Legislation Introduction The personal scope of application of EC social and employment law The directions of development of EC law Conclusions: a theoretical structure for the personal scope of EC social and employment law 147 147 147 154 161 168 171 172 191 197 EC Regulation of Atypical Forms of Work – Between Employment Law and Employment Policy 205 Introduction EC legislative measures on atypical work 207 The EU notions of ‘flexibility’, ‘security’ and ‘flexicurity’ 211 Looking at the national employment policies through the distorting mirror of National Action Plans and Employment Recommendations 220 Divergences between EES and EC employment law on atypical work and the European Court of Justice 227 Conclusions 231 Bibliography Index 237 247 Table of Cases European Court of Justice Alphabetical list Barber v Guardian Royal Exchange (Case C-262/88 ) [1990] ECR I-1889 291 Bestuur van de Sociale Verzekeringsbank v M G J Kits van Heijningen (Case C-2/89) [1990] ECR I-1755 287 Bettray v Staatssecretaris van Justitie (Case 344/87) [1989] ECR 1621 [1991] CMLR 280, 312 Bilka-Kaufhaus Gmbh v Weber von Hartz (Case 170/84 ) [1986] ECR 1607 174, 290 C.P.M Meeusen v Hoofddirectie van de Informatie Beheer Groep (Case C-337/97) [1999] ECR I-3289 [2000] CMLR 667 278, 311, 313 Criminal Proceedings against Carra and others (Case C-258/98) [2000] ECR I-4217 [2002] CMLR 195 Debra Allonby v Accrington & Rossendale College and others (Case C-256/01) (Judgement of 13 January 2004) 91, 216, 217, 292-295, 315, 360 Defrenne v Sabena (Case 149/77) [1978] ECR 1365 315 Deutsche Post AG v Elisabeth Sievers and Brunhilde Schrage (Joined cases C-270/97 and C-271/97) [2000] ECR I 929 315 E.C Commission v Belgium (Re Access to Special Employment Programmes) (C-278/94) [1996] ECR I-4307 312 EJM de Jaeck v Staatssecretaris van Financiën (Case C-340/94) [1997] ECR I-00461 287, 314 Foreningen af Arbejdsledere i Danmark v A/S Danmols Inventar (Case 105/84) [1985] ECR 2639 303, 306, 318 Galinsky v Insurance Office (Case 99/80) [1981] ECR 941 287 Gerster v Freistaat Bayern (Case C-1/95) [1997] ECR I-5253 [1998] CMLR 303 176 Hoekstra (née Unger) v Bestuur der Bedrijfsvereniging voor Detailhandel en Ambachten (Case 75/63) [1964] ECR 177 277, 287, 314 Inge Nolte v Landesversicherungsanstalt Hannover (Case C-317/93) [1995] ECR I-4625 155 Jenkins v Kingsgate (Case 96/80) [1981] ECR 911 290 Job Centre Coop arl (Case C-55/96) [1997] ECR I-7119 [1998] CMLR 708 195 Jyri Lehtonen and Another v FRBSB (Case C-176/96) [2000] ECR I-2681 [2000] CMLR 409 281 viii The Changing Law of the Employment Relationship Klaus Höfner and Fritz Elser v Macrotron GmbH (Case C-41/90) [1991] ECR I 1979 [1993] CMLR 306 195 Kording v Senator für Finanzen (Case C-100/95) [1997] ECR I-5289 [1998] CMLR 395 173, 176 Kowalska v Freie und Hansestadt Hamburg (Case 33/89 ) [1990] ECR I-2591 174, 290 Lawrie-Blum v Land Baden-Württemberg (Case 66/85) [1986] ECR 2121 [1987] CMLR 414 278, 312 Levin v Secretary of State for Justice (Case 53/81) [1982] ECR 1035 [1982] CMLR 467 277, 278, 311, 312 Martίnez Sala v Freistat Bayern (Case C-85/96) [1998] ECR I-2691 281, 312 Mary Carpenter v Secretary of State for the Home Department (C-60/00) [2002] ECR I 6279 313 P v S and Cornwall County Council (Case C-13/94) [1996] ECR I-2143 315 R v Secretary for Trade and Industry ex parte Broadcasting, Entertainment, Cinematographic and Theatre Union (BECTU) (Case C-173/99) [2001] ECR I- 4881 299, 300 R v Secretary of State, ex p Seymour-Smith and Perez (Case C-167/97) [1999] ECR I-623 [1999] CMLR 322 152, 189, 190, 290 Raulin v Minister van Onderwijs en Wetenschappen (Case C-357/89) [1992] ECR I-1027 [1994] CMLR 227 279, 312, 295 Razzouk and Beydoun v Commission (Joined Cases 75/82 and 117/82) [1984] ECR 1509 315 Reinhard Gebhard v Consiglio dell’Ordine degli Avvocati e Procuratori di Milano (Case C-55/94) [1995] ECR I-4165 282, 283 Rinner-Kuhn (Case 171/88) [1989] ECR 2743 174, 290 Secretary of State for the Home Department v Hacene Akrich (Case C-109/01) [2003] ECR 313 Shirley Preston and Others v Wolverhampton Healthcare NHS Trust and Others (Case C-78/98) [2000] ECR I-3201 115, 116, 290-292, 315 Steymann v Staatssecrretaris van Justitie (Case 196/87) [1988] ECR 6159 [1989] CMLR 449 280, 312 Union Royale Belge des Sociétés de Football Association (ASBL) v Bosman Case (C-415/93) [1995] ECR I-4921 [1996] CMLR 645 281 United Kingdom Alphabetical list BBC v Ioannou [1975] ICR 267 151 BBC v Kelly-Phillips [1998] ICR 587 [1998] IRLR 294 151 Carmichael v National Power plc [1999] ICR 1226 83, 85, 105, 114, 116, 139, 295 Clarke v Powell and Eley (IMI) Kynoch Ltd [1982] IRLR 131 180 Table of Cases ix Cloroll Pension Trustees Ltd v Russell [1994] IRLR 586 180 Clymo v Wandsworth Borough Council [1989] IRLR 241 179 Construction Industry Training Board v Labour Force Ltd (1970) All ER 220 66, 168 Dacas v Brooks Street Bureau (UK) Ltd [2003] IRLR 190 166, 167 Debra Allonby v Accrington & Rossendale College [2001] IRLR 354 217 Devonald v Rosser & Sons Ltd [1906] KB 728 46 Emmens v Eldertonn (1853) 13 CB 495 36 England v The Governing Body of Turnford School [2003] WL 21047416 207 Franks v Reuters Ltd [2003] IRLR 423 167, 168 Hall v Lorimer [1994] ICR 218 103 Hanley v Pease & Partners [1915] KB 698 46 Hewlett Packard v O’Murphy [2002] IRLR 168 Home Office v Holmes [1984] IRLR 299 179, 180 Ironmonger v Movefield Ltd t/a Deerings Appointments [1988] IRLR 461 (EAT) 90, 162, 168 Kidd v DRG (UK) Ltd [1985] IRLR 190 180 Lancaster v Greaves (1829) B & C 627 36 Lane v Shire Roofing Company (Oxford) Ltd [1995] IRLR 493 (CA) 102 Market Investigations Ltd v Minister of Social Security [1969] QB 173 57 McMeechan v Secretary of State for Employment [1995] ICR 444 [1995] IRLR 461 66, 162, 165 Montgomery v Johnson Underwood Ltd [2001] ICR 819 IRLR 269 90, 162, 165, 166, 170 Montreal v Monteral Locomotive Works [1947] DLR 161 57, 102, 103 Morren v Swinton and Pedelebury Borough Council [1965] WLR 576 55 Motorola Ltd v Davidson [2001] IRLR 165 O’Kelly v Trusthouse Forte Plc [1983] ICR 728 [1984] QB 90 83, 103, 105, 114, 116, 132, 139, 295 O’Sullivan v Thompson-Coon (1972) 14 KIR 108 66, 164 Preston v Wolverhampton Healthcare NHS Trust [2001] UKHL (2001), [2001] ICR 217 115, 116 R v Secretary of State, ex p Seymour-Smith and Perez [1994] IRLR 448 [1995] IRLR 464, CA [1997] IRLR 315 HL 152, 189, 190 Ready Mixed Concrete (South East) Ltd v Minister of Pensions and National Insurance [1968] QB 497 55, 103 Simmons v Heath Laundry Co [1910] KB 543 45 Simpson v Ebbw Vale Steel, Iron & Coal Co [1905] KB 453 40 Staffordshire County Council v Black [1995] IRLR 234 180 Stevenson, Jordan & Harrison v MacDonald & Evans [1952] TLR 101 56 Underwood v Perry [1932] W.C & I Rep 63 45 Wickens v Champion Employment [1984] ICR 365 162, 165 Yewens v Noakes (1880) QBD 530 54 Bibliography Books and monographs A Alcock, History of the International Labour Organization (Macmillan, London, 1971) G Altieri and C Oteri, Terzo rapporto sul lavoro atipico in Italia: verso la stabilizzazione del precariato? (IRES-CGIL 2003) A Amin, Post-Fordism: a Reader (Blackwell, Oxford, 1994) A Arnull, A.A Dashwood, M G Gross and D A Wyatt, European Union Law (4th edn Sweet & Maxwell, London 2000) J Arrowsmith, Temporary Agency Work in an Enlarged European Union (Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg, 2006) D Ashiagbor, The European Employment Strategy – Labour Market Regulation and New Governance (OUP, Oxford, 2005) L Barassi, Il contratto di lavoro nel diritto positivo Italiano (Societa’ editrice libraria, Milano, 1901) B Bercusson, European Labour Law (London, Butterworths, 1996) D Brodie, A History of British Labour Law (Hart, Oxford, 2003) C Barnard, EC Employment Law (2nd ed OUP, Oxford, 2000) G H Camerlynck and G Lyon-Caen, Droit du travail (Dalloz, Paris, 1976) G H Camerlynck, Le Contrat de Travail (2nd edn, Dalloz, Paris, 1982) U Carabelli and B Veneziani (eds.), Du travail salarié au travail indépendant: permanences et mutations (Cacucci, Bari, 2003) S Clauwaert, Legal Analysis of the Implementation of the Fixed-term Work DirectiveReport 76 (ETUI, Brussels, 2003) S Clauwaert, Survey on the implementation of the Part-time Work Directive/ Agreement in the EU member states and selected applicant countries - Report 73 (ETUI, Brussels, 2002) H Collins and K Ewing and A McColgan, Labour Law (Hart, Oxford, 2001) H Collins, P.L Davies and R.W Rideout, Legal Regulation of the Employment Relation (Kluwer, London, 2000) J.A.-M Coyle Shapiro, L.M Shore, M.S Taylor, and L.E Tetrick (eds), The Employment Relationship – Examining Psychological and Contextual Perspectives (OUP, Oxford, 2004) P Craig and G De Burca, EU Law - Text, Cases and Materials (2nd edn, OUP, Oxford, 1998) P.L Davies, ‘The Relationship Between the European Court of Justice and the British Courts over the interpretation of Directive 77/187/EC’ (Working Paper No European University Institute, 1997) P Davies and M Freedland, Labour Legislation and Public policy: a Contemporary 238 The Changing Law of the Employment Relationship History (Clarendon, Oxford, 1993) R De Luca Tamajo, ‘Dal lavoro parasubordinato al lavoro “a progetto”’ (Working paper No 25 CSDLE ‘Massimo d’Antona’, 2003) S Deakin, ‘The Contract of Employment: a Study in Legal Evolution’ (working paper No 203 ESRC Centre for Business Research University of Cambridge, June 2001) S Deakin, ‘The many futures of the Contract of Employment’ (Working Paper No 191 ESRC Centre for Business Research University of Cambridge, December 2000) S Deakin and G Morris Labour Law (3rd ed Butterworths London 2001) S Deakin and G Morris Labour Law (Hart, Oxford, 2005) S Deakin, The Contract of Employment: a Study in Legal Evolution (ESCR Working paper No 203, June 2001) S Deakin, The many futures of the contract of employment (CBR Working Paper No 191, December 2001) S Deakin, The Comparative Evolution of the Employment Relationship (Working Paper No 317 ESRC Centre for Business Research University of Cambridge December 2005) S Deakin and F Wilkinson, The Law of the Labour Market – Industrialization, Employment and Legal Evolution (OUP, Oxford, 2005) DTI, Discussion Document on Employment Status in Relation to Statutory Employment Rights July 2002, mainly page 26 and following Available on http:// www.dti.gov.uk/er/individual/statusdiscuss.pdf (15 January 2004) DTI, Explanatory memorandum on European Community Legislation - Amended proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on temporary work submitted on 10 January 2003 and available on http://www.dti gov.uk/er/agency/em.htm (15 January 2004) DTI, Fixed-term work: a guidance to the regulations (DTI, London, 2001) DTI, Revision of the Regulations covering the private recruitment industry – Regulatory impact assesment (June 2002) K Ewing, Working Life –A New Perspective on Labour Law (Lawrence & Wishart, London, 1996) A Fox, Beyond Contract: work, power and trust relations (Faber, London, 1974) S Fredman, Discrimination Law ( Clarendon, Oxford, 2002) M Freedland, The Contract of Employment (Clarendon, Oxford, 1976) M Freedland, The Personal Employment Contract (OUP, Oxford, 2003) French Ministry of Employment, ‘Le temps partiel subi diminue depuis 1998’ Premières informations et Premières Synthèses 10 n 42.2 (Direction de l’animation de la recherche, des études et des statistiques du Ministère de l’emploi, Paris, 2001) G Gembillo (ed), W Heisenberg - Indeterminazione e realtà (Guida, Napoli, 1991) E Ghera, Diritto del Lavoro (Cacucci, Bari, 1998) E Ghera, Diritto del Lavoro (Cacucci, Bari, 2000) E Ghera, Diritto del Lavoro (Cacucci, Bari, 2002) E Ghera, Diritto del Lavoro (Cacucci, Bari, 2006) P A Hall and D Soskice, Varieties of Capitalism – The Institutional Foundations of Bibliography 239 Comparative Advantage (OUP, Oxford, 2001) U Hotopp, Recruitment agencies in the UK (DTI, 2001) P Ichino, Il tempo della prestazione nel rapporto di lavoro (Giuffrè Milano 1985), Vol II Estensione temporale della prestazione lavorativa subordinata e relative forme speciali di organizzazione C Knill and D Lehmkuhl, ‘How Europe Matter: Different Mechanisms of Europeanization’ (1999) European Integration online Papers (EIoP) No Y Kravaritou-Manitakis (ed), New Forms of Work – Labour Law and Social Security aspects in the European Community (Dublin, European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions, 1988) R Lewis and J Clark, Labour Law and Politics in the Weimar Republic- Otto KahnFreund (Blackwell, Oxford, 1981) D Mardsen, A Theory of Employment Systems (OUP, Oxford, 1999) K Marx, Capital – A Critical Analysis of Capitalist Production Volume (Lawrence & Wishart, London, 1974) A Mazeaud, Droit du travail (LGDJ Montchrestien, Paris, 2002) R Nielsen and E Szyszczak, The Social Dimension of the European Union (Handelshøjskolens Forlag, Copenhagen, 1997) L Nogler, ‘La certificazione dei contratti di lavoro’ (Working paper No 23 CSDLE ‘Massimo d’Antona’, 2003)’ J Pélissier, A Supiot and A Jeammaud, Droit du Travail (Dalloz, Paris, 2000) J Pélissier, A Supiot and A Jeammaud, Droit du Travail (Dalloz, Paris, 2006) A Perulli, Economically dependent / quasi-subordinate (parasubordinate) employment: legal, social and economic aspects (Brussels, 2003) M Piore and C Sabel, The Second Industrial Divide: Possibilities for Prosperity (Basic Books, New York, 1984) M Rodriguez-Pinero y Bravo Ferrer, Individual dismissal in the Member States of the European Community: The Advantages and Difficulty of Community Action Report for the Commission of the EC, DGV V/5767/93 EN R Rowthorn and R Ramaswamy, Deindustrialization – Its Causes and Implications (IMF Publication Services, Washington, 1997) A Supiot (ed), Au delà de l’emploi Transformations du travail et devenir du droit du travail en Europe (Flammarion, Paris, 1999) A Supiot, Beyond Employment Changes in Work and the Future of Labour Law in Europe (OUP, Oxford 2001) A Supiot, Critique du Droit du Travail (PUF, Paris, 2002) TUC, The Hidden One-in-Five – Winning a Fair Deal for Britain’s Vulnerable Workers (2006) S Walby to the House of Commons Select Committee on Education and Employment in Part-Time Working (volume 2, 2nd report 1998-99) M Weiss, European Employment and Industrial Relations Glossary: Germany (Sweet & Maxwell, London, 1992) M Weiss and M Schmidt, Labour Law and Industrial Relations in Germany (3rd edn Kluwer, The Hague, 2000) K Zweigert and H Kötz An Introduction to Comparative Law (2nd edn Clarendon 240 The Changing Law of the Employment Relationship Oxford 1987) 41 Contributions to books P Alleva, ‘Ridefinizione della fattispecie di contratto dellavoro Prima proposta di legge’ in G Ghezzi (ed), La disciplina del mercato del lavoro, proposte per un testo unico (Ediesse, Roma, 1996), 195 U Carabelli, ‘Flessibilizzazione o Destrutturazione del Mercato del Lavoro? Il Lavoro Interninale in Italia ed in Europa’ in Scritti in Onore di Giugni (Cacucci, Bari, 1999), 185 B Coriat, ‘Technical flexibility and mass production’ in G Benk and M Dunford (eds.), Industrial Change and Regional Development (Belhaven, London, 1991), 150 M D’Antona, ‘Ridefinizione della fattispecie di contratto di lavoro Seconda proposta di legge’ in G Ghezzi (ed), La disciplina del mercato del lavoro, proposte per un testo unico (Ediesse, Roma,, 1996) 95 P Davies, ‘Transfer of Undertakings’ in S Sciarra, Labour Law in the Courts: National Judges and the European Court of Justice (Hart, Oxford, 2001), 130 P Davies and M Freedland, ‘Employees, workers, and the autonomy of labour law’ in H Collins, P Davies and R Rideout (eds), The Legal Regulation of the Employment Relation (Kluwer, London, 2000), 275 P Davies and M Freedland, ‘Changing Perspectives Upon the Employment Relationship in British Labour Law’, in C Barnard, S Deakin and G Morris, The Future of Labour Law – Liber Amicorum Sir Bob Hepple (Oxford, 2004), 129 R De Luca Tamajo and R Flammia and M Persiani ‘La crisi della nozione di subordinazione e della sua idoneità selettiva dei trattamenti garantistici Prime proposte per un nuovo approccio sistematico in una prospettiva di valorizzazione di un tertium genus: il lavoro coordinato’ in AA.VV Nuove forme di lavoro tra subordinazione, coordinazione, autonomiab (Cacucci, Bari 1997) S Deakin, ‘The Evolution of the Contract of Employment, 1900-1950’ in N Whiteside and R Salais, Governance, Industry and Labour Markets is Britain and France – The Modernising State in the mid-twentieth Century (Routledge, London, 1998), 213 S Deakin and H Reed, ‘The Contested Meaning of Labour Market Flexibility: Economic Theory and the Discourse of European Integration’ in J Shaw (ed), Social Law and Policy in an Evolving European Union (Oxford, Hart, 2000) S Fredman, ‘Discrimination in the EU: Labour market regulation or fundamental rights?’ in H Collins, P Davies and R Rideout (eds), Legal Regulation of the Employment Relation (Kluwer, The Hague, 2000), 183 M Freedland, ‘Employment Policy’ in P Davies, A Lyon-Caen, S Sciarra and S Simitis (eds), European Community Labour Law Principles and Perspectives on European Labour Law: Liber Amicorum Lord Wedderburn of Charlton (Clarendon, Oxford, 1996), 308 M Freedland, ‘The role of the contract of employment in modern labour law’ in L Betten (ed), The Employment Contract in Transforming Labour Relations Bibliography 241 (Kluwer, Deventer, 1995), 17 M Freedland and C Kilpatrick, ‘The United Kingdom: how is EU governance transformative? in S Sciarra, P Davies and M Freedland (eds), Employment Policy and the Regulation of Part-time Work in the European Union A Comparative Analysis (CUP, Cambridge, 2004) E Ghera, ‘Subordinazione, statuto protettivo e qualificazione del rapporto di lavoro’, in D Garofalo and M Ricci (eds), Percorsi di Diritto del Lavoro (Cacucci, Bari, 2006), 332 G Giugni, ‘Aspects Juridiques de l’Économie Informelle’ in Les transformations du droit du travail – Études offertes Gérard Lyon-Caen (Dalloz, Paris, 1989), 259 A C Neal, ‘Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations: ‘Major Discipline?’ – Who Cares?’ in C Engels and M Weiss (eds), Labour Law and Industrial Relations at the Turn of the Century – Liber Amicorum in Honour of Prof Dr Roger Blanpain (Kluwer Law International, The Hague, 1998), 55 V Pinto, ‘ La categoria giuridica delle collaborazioni coordinate e continuative e il lavoro a progetto’, in P Curzio (ed), Lavoro e diritti a tre anni dalla legge 30/2003 (Cacucci, Bari, 2006), 431 M.V Roheling ,’Legal Theory: Contemporary Contract Law Perspectives and Insights for Employment Relationship Theory’ in J.A.-M Coyle Shapiro, L.M Shore, M.S Taylor and L.E Tetrick (eds), The Employment Relationship – Examining Psychological and Contextual Perspectives (Oxford, 2004), 76 C Smith, ‘From Automation to Flexible Specialization’ in A Pollert, Farewell to Flexibility? (Blackwell, Oxford, 1991), 155 J Tomaney, ‘New Work Organization and Technology’ in A Amin (ed), PostFordism: a Reader (Blackwell, Oxford, 1994), 164 B Veneziani, ‘The Evolution of the Contract of Employment’ in B Hepple (ed) The Making of Labour Law in Europe: A Comparative Study of Nine Countries up to 1945 (Mansell, London, 1986), 35 T Walsh, ‘Flexible Employment in the Retail and Hotel Trades’ in A Pollert, Farewell to Flexibility? (Blackwell, Oxford, 1991), 104 M Weber, ‘The Origins of Industrial Capitalism in Europe’ in W.G Runciman (ed), Weber Selections in Translations (CUP, Cambridge, 1978), 335 K W W Wedderburn, ‘The Right to Strike: Is There a European Standard?’ in K.W W Wedderburn, Employment Rights in Britain and Europe: selected papers (Lawrence & Wishart, London, 1991), 289 Articles ‘Political and Economic Planning’ (1956) Planning, 405 ‘Reforms to boost labour market’ (2003) 349 EIRR, 27 ‘Social Aspects of European Economic Cooperation’ (1956) ILR, 99 ‘The EU and the Modernisation on Labour Law First Stage Consultation of Social Partners on modernising and improving employment relations’ (2000) 16 242 The Changing Law of the Employment Relationship IJCLLIR, 436 B Alibert, ‘Le contrat de travail temporaire’ (1974) DS, 10 J Atkinson, ‘Flexibility or Fragmentation? The UK Labour Market in the Eighties’ (1987) Labour and Society, 87 V Ballestrero, ‘L’ambigua nozione di lavoro parasubordinato’ (1987) Lavoro e Diritto, 41 M Biagi, ‘Italy’, (1999) BCLR, 274 R Castel, ‘Droit du travail: redéploiement ou refondation?’ (1999) DS, 441 R H Coase, ‘The Nature of the Firm’ (1937) Economica, 386 H Collins, ‘Employment Rights of Casual Workers’ (2000) ILJ, 73 H Collins, ‘Flexibility and Stability of Expectations in the Contract of Employment’ (2006) Socio-Economic Review, 139 W Däubler, ‘Working people in Germany’ (1999) Comp Labor Law & Pol’y Journal, 78 W Däubler and M Le Friant, ‘Un récent exemple de flexibilisation législative: la loi allemande pour la promotion de l’emploi du 26 avril 1985’ (1985) DS, 715 G Davidov, ‘Who is a Worker?’ (2005) ILJ, 57 A Davies, ‘Casual Workers and Continuity of Employment’ (2006) ILJ, 196 S Deakin, ‘The Changing Concept of ‘Employer’ in Labour Law’ (2001) ILJ, 75 E Dockès, ‘Du CNE au CPE, après le jugement du Conseil de prud’hommes de Longjumeau’ (2006) DS, 356 F Favennec-Héry, ‘Le travail temps partiel: changement de cap’ (1999) DS, 1005 F Favennec-Héry, ‘Le travail temps partiel’ (1994) DS, 165 F Favennec-Héry, ‘Le temps vraiment choisi’ (2000) DS, 295 G Ferraro, ‘Dal lavoro subordinato al lavoro autonomo’ (1998) GDLRI, 461 F A Flammand and M.-L Morin, ‘L’activité professionnelle indépendante: quelle protection juridique ?’ (2001) 346 Le Notes du Lirhe, S Fredman, ‘Women at Work: The Broken Promise of Flexicurity’, (2004) ILJ, 305 M Freedland, ‘Equal Treatment, Judicial Review and Delegated Legislation’ (1994) ILJ, 255 M Freedland, ‘From the Contract of Employment to the Personal Work Nexus’ (2005) ILJ, M Freedland e N Countouris, ‘Diritti e doveri nel rapporto tra disoccupati e servizi per l’impiego in Europa’ (2005) GDLRI, 557 M Fuchs, ‘Germania’ (2000) GDLRI, 593 L Gaeta, ‘Lodovico Barassi, Philipp Lotmar e la cultura giuridica tedesca’ (2001) GDLRI, 176 A Garilli, ‘Il contratto di lavoro e il rapporto di impiego privato nella teoria di Lodovico Barassi’ (2001) RGL, 375 M G Garofalo, ‘La legge delaga sul mercato del lavoro: prime osservazioni’ (2003) RGL, 359 M G Garofalo, ‘Un Profilo Ideologico del Diritto del Lavoro’ (1999) GDLRI, G Giugni, ‘Giuridificazione e deregolazione nel diritto del lavoro italiano’ (1986) Bibliography 243 GDLRI, 331 B Hepple, ‘European Rules on Dismissal Law’ (1997) CLLJ, 204 B Hepple, ‘Restructuring Employment Rights’ (1986) ILJ, 69 B Hepple, ‘United Kingdom’ (1999) BCLR, 380 A Hoeland, ‘A Comparative Study of the Impact of Electronic Technology on Workplace Disputes: National Report on Germany’ (2005) Comp Labor Law & Pol’y Journal, 152 A Jeammaud, ‘L’assimilation des franchisés aux salariés’ (2002) DS, 158 A Jeammaud, ‘L’avenir sauvegardé de la qualification de contrat de travail À propos de l’ arrêt Labanne’ (2001) DS, 227 O Kahn-Freund, ‘Servants and Independent Contractors’ (1951) MLR, 505 O Kahn-Freund, ‘Blackstone’s neglected child: the contract of Employment’ (1977) LQR, 508 O Kahn-Freund, ‘Status and Contract in Labour Law’ (1967) MLR, 642 O Kahn-Freund, ‘Uses and Misuses of Comparative Law’ (1974) 37 MLR, O Kahn-Freund, ‘A note on status and contract in modern labour law’ (1967) MLR, 635 S Laulom, ‘Francia’ (2000) GDLRI, 559 S Leonardi, ‘Il lavoro coordinato e continuativo: profili giuridici e aspetti normativi’ (1999) RGL, S Leonardi, ‘Parasubordinazione e Contrattazione Collettiva Una Lettura Trasversale degli Accordi Siglati’ (2001) Quaderni di Rassegna Sindacale, A Lyon-Caen, ‘Actualité du contrat de travail, brefs propos’ (1988) DS, 541 A Lyon-Caen, ‘Le recours au travail durée limitée’ (1983) DS, 18 A Lyon-Caen, ‘Plasticité du capital et nouvelles formes d’emploi’ (1983) Special issue Sept-Oct DS, 10 U Müchenberger, R Wank and H Buchner, ‘Ridefinire la nozione di subordinazione? Il dibattito in Germania’ (2000) GDLRI, 329 L Nogler, ‘Sulla inutilità delle presunzioni legali relative in tema di qualificazione dei rapporti di lavoro’ (1997) RIDL, 311 J Pelissier, ‘Travail durée limitée et droits des salariés’ (1983) DS, 18 G Pera, ‘Sulle prospettive di estensione delle tutele al lavoro parasubordinato’ (1998) RIDL, 371 P Pigassou, ‘L’ évolution du lien de subordination en droit du travail et de la Sécurité sociale’ (1982) DS, 578 G Poulain, ‘La loi du janvier 1979 relative au contrat de travail durée déterminée’ (1979) DS, 68 P Saint-Jevin, ‘Existe-t-il un droit commun du contrat de travail?’ (1981) DS, 517 M Schneider, ‘A juridical Approach to the Notion of Independent Labour A Critical Study of the French and German Systems’ (2000) IJCLLIR, 337 J Schregle, ‘Comparative Industrial Relations’ (1981) ILR,15 A Supiot, ‘Les nouveaux visages de la subordination’ (2000) DS, 139 B Teyssié, ‘La loi du 28 janvier 1981 sur le travail temps partiel’ (1981) DS, 520 B Veneziani, ‘Contratto di lavoro, potere di controllo e subordinazione nell’opera di 244 The Changing Law of the Employment Relationship Ludovico Barassi’ (2002) GDLRI, 39 R Wank, ‘Germany’(2005) BCLR, 19 M Weiss, ‘Germany’(1999) BCLR, 255 L Zappalà, ‘The Temporary Agency Workers’ Directive: An Impossible Political Agreement?’ (2003) ILJ, 310 ILO and EC materials (selected) International Labour Organisation: ILO, Contract Labour- Report VI (1) to the International Labour Conference 85th Session 1997 (Geneva, 1996) ILO, Contract labour- Fifth item on the agenda Report V (1) to the International Labour Conference 86th Session 1998 (Geneva, 1997) Committee on Contract Labour, Record of Proceedings, International Labour Conference 86th Session Vol II (Geneva, 1998) International Labour Conference (87th Session), Decent work - Report of the DirectorGeneral (Geneva, June 1999) ILO, Second Item on the Agenda Governing Body 280th Session GB 280/2 (Geneva, March 2001) International Labour Conference (90th Session), Report VI Decent Work in the informal economy – Sixth item on the agenda (Geneva, June 2002) ILO, International Labour Conference Report V- The scope of the employment relationship – fifth item on the agenda (Geneva, 2003) International Labour Conference (91st session), Report V- The scope of the employment relationship – fifth item on the agenda (Geneva, June 2003) International Labour Conference (91st Session), Provisional Record No 21 (Geneva, June 2003) ILO International Labour Conference, Report V(1) – The Employment Relationship – Fifth Item on the Agenda (Geneva, June 2005) ILO International Labour Conference, Report V(2A) – The Employment Relationship – Fifth Item on the Agenda (Geneva, June 2006) European Community: Communication from the Commission Concerning its Action Programme relating to the Implementation of the Community Charter of Basic Social Rights for Workers COM(89) 568 final EC Commission, Green paper – Partnership for a new organisation of work COM (97) 128 final 16.4.1997 EC Commission, Communication Modernising the Organisation of work – A positive approach to change COM(98) 592 final 12.10.1998 EC Commission DGV, Commission Draft for the Joint Employment Report 1997 Brussels, 30 September 1997 EC Commission DGV, Joint Employment Report Employment Policies in the EU Bibliography 245 and in the Member States – Joint Report 1998 (1999) EC Commission, Joint Employment Report 2000 EC Commission, Joint Employment Report 2001 EC Commission, Joint Employment Report 2002 EC Commission, Report by the Commission’s Services on the Implementation of Council Directive 97/81/EC of 17 December 1997 Concerning the Framework Agreement in Part-time Work Concluded by UNICE, CEEP and the ETUC (Brussels, 2003) EC Commission, Joint Employment Report 2005/2006 ‘More and Better Jobs: Delivering the Priorities of the European Employment Strategy’ (2006) EC Commission, Green Paper ‘Modernising Labour Law to Meet the Challenges of the 21st Century’ COM(2006) 708 final European Employment Taskforce, Jobs, Jobs, Jobs – Creating More Employment In Europe (2003) Flexibilité du temps de travail et sécurité des travailleurs – première phase de consultation avec les partenaires sociaux conformément a l’article de l’accord social annexe au traite SEC(95) 1540/3 The Government of France, Plan National pour l’Emploi 2000 The Government of France, National Action Plan for Employment 2001 and Overview of 2000 – France (May 2001) The Government of France, National Action Plan for Employment 2002 - France (June 2002) The Government of Italy, National Action Plan for Employment Implementation Report, Year 2000 – Italy (April 2000) The Government of Italy, 2001 National Action Plan for Employment (May 2001) The Government of Italy, Italia - Piano Nazionale per l’ Occupazione (Giugno 2002) This page intentionally left blank Index accidents, work-related 23–4 agency workers 38–9, 159–60 see also temporary agency work angestellter 35 apprentices 18 arbeitnehmerahnliche atypical employment relationship 87–9 see also fixed-term work; part-time work; temporary agency work definition 208 European Community (EC) 207–10, 219–20 International Labour Organization (ILO) 154–61 availability compensation 141 Biagi Law 8, 139–40, 225 bilaterality 38–9, 52 Britain see United Kingdom capitalism 17 casual workers 27, 41, 48–9, 155, 183, 184, 188 see also decasualisation Collaborazioni Coordinate e Continuative (co.co.co) 8, 72–3, 76–7 collective bargaining 27, 28–9 commodity exchange 19 compagnons 18 comparative legal analysis 9–12 continuity of employment 34–9, 48–50, 69 contract labour 159–62 contracts of employment 153 see also employment relationship common law 19 continuity 48–50 contract of service 28 European Community (EC) 189–91 France 21–2 Germany 22–3 industrial revolution 16–25 intermediation 38–9 Italy 22, 32 legal presumptions 63–4 manual workers 27 personal 82 reform of 52–4 Roman Law 19 unitary notion of 25–39, 40 United Kingdom 19–21, 30 contracts of service 20, 28 contrat première embauche (CPE) contratto a progetto 76–7 control test 26–7, 31, 45–6 decasualisation 37 see also casual workers Decent Work 162–3 Diensvertrag 23 EC see European Community economic dependency 33, 64–6, 192–3 economic determinism economic reality 33 EES see European Employment Strategy employee status intermittent work 68–71 judicial intervention 60–63 qualifying period 68–9 qualitative exclusions 59–68 quantitative exclusions 68–71 statutory intervention 63–8 employees 58–71, 153–4 see also workers definition 36, 66 employment agencies 38–9, 50–52, 97, 157–61, 207 employment businesses 97–8 employment contracts see contracts of employment employment law 29 248 The Changing Law of the Employment Relationship comparative study 10–11 European Community (EC) 193–7, 219–20, 228–9 human resource management reform 81–3, 193–7 scope of 5, 59–68 employment policy 229 employment relationship see also contract of employment atypical 87–9 see also fixed-term work; part-time work; temporary agency work bilaterality 38–9, 52 binary 3, 29 breakdown 39–52 contractual framework 52–4 deregulation 42–5 discontinuity 47–8 disguised 163–4 European Community (EC) 187, 189–91 intermediation 50–52 intermittence 47–8 International Labour Organization (ILO) 161–8 legal dimension 2–3 long-term 34–9 multilaterality 50–52 origins 16–17 regulation 4–7, 42–5 scope of 161–8 substitution 47 triangular 163–6 see also temporary agency work trilaterality 50–52 enhanced autonomy 45–7 equal pay 180–82 equal treatment 6–7, 208–9, 214, 220–21 temporary agency work 229 equality 18–19 equality law in the European Community 179–85 European Community (EC) atypical work 207–10, 219–20 contracts of employment 189–91 discrimination law 184–5 economic dependency 192–3 employment agencies 207 Employment Guidelines 216 employment law 228–9 atypical work 219–20 reform 193–7 employment relationship 187, 189–91 equal pay 180–82 European Employment Strategy (EES) 211–30 fixed-term work directive 131–2, 188, 209–10 flexicurity 211–12, 217–19 framing policy 227–8 free movement of workers 172–7 health and safety law 185–6 job-seekers 174–5 Modernising Labour Law to Meet the Challenges of the 21st Century (Green Paper) 193–7 part-time work 173 Directive 122–3, 127–8, 188, 209 Partnership for a New Organisation of Work (Green Paper) 212–13 pensions 177–8, 181 posted workers 176–7 provision of services 175–6 regulatory integration 227–8 restructuring 187 right of establishment 175–6 self-employed workers 175–6, 182 Social Charter 207 social security 177–8 temporary agency work 210 transfer of undertakings 187 working conditions 186–91 European Employment Strategy (EES) 211–30 2003 Guidelines 215 adaptability pillar 213–15 flexible working 214–16 flexicurity 214, 220–27 framing policy 228 job security 214–15 policy priorities 215 quality of work 215 exclusive service 20–21 fixed-term work 89–92, 131–6, 229 contracts 6, 29 European Community Directive 131–2, 188, 209–10 regulation 110–16 Index flexibility 226 flexibility and security see flexicurity flexible working 214–16 flexicurity 211–12, 214, 217–19, 220–27 framework contracts 70 France contract of employment 21–2 legal presumptions 63–4 fixed-term work 90–91, 133–4, 135 regulation 111–12 flexicurity 222, 223, 224, 225, 226 judicial intervention in employment law 60 part-time work 92–3 flexibility 130 Part-time Work Directive 122 regulation 105–7 special rights 126 subordination 60 temporary agency work 96 regulation 116–18 freedom 18–19 freedom of contract 19 Germany contract of employment 22–3 decasualisation 37 economic dependency 65–6 fixed-term work 90, 132–3, 134 regulation 114–15 Kapovaz 107–8 part-time work 93–4 regulation 107–8 special rights 126 Personal-Service-Agenturen (PSA) 138 quasi-subordination 72, 78 self-employed workers 66 social security legislation 65–6, 78 subordination 60 temporary agency work 95–6, 229 equal pay 139–9 regulation 118–19, 137–9 guild system 17–18 health and safety law in the European Community 185–6 homeworking 47, 153, 157 human resource management 249 impiegato 35–6 industrial revolution 16–25 injuries, work-related 23–4 integration test 33, 47 intermediation 38–9, 50–52 intermittent work 68–71, 148 International Labour Organization (ILO) agency workers 159–60 atypical work 154–61 contract labour 159–62 contract of employment 153 Decent Work 162–3 employees 153–4 employment agencies 157–61 employment relationship 161–8 fundamental rights at work 156, 158 home work 153, 157 instruments, personal scope of 147–54 part-time work 154–6 quasi-subordination 160–61 self-employed workers 151, 153–4, 159–60 temporary agency work 157–61, 163–6 workers 148, 149–50, 151–4 Italy availability compensation 141 collective agreements 74 continuity of employment 69 contract of employment 22, 32 preventive certification 66–7 contratto a progetto 76–7 fixed-term work 90, 133, 134 regulation 112–14 flexicurity 222, 223, 224–5, 227 part-time work 94, 105 regulation 108–9 special rights 126–7 quasi-subordination 72–8 Smuraglia proposal 75 staff-leasing 140–41 subordination 60–61, 64–5 temporary agency work 96–7 flexibility 141 regulation 119–20, 139–41 job rotation 214 job security 29–30, 214–15 see also flexicurity job-seekers 174–5 250 The Changing Law of the Employment Relationship job-sharing 108 judicial intervention in employment law 60–63 Kapovaz 107–8 labour legislation livret ouvrier 22 locatio conductio locatio d’ouvrage louage de service Personal-Service-Agenturen (PSA) 138 personality test 47 posted workers 176–7 production, modes of 18 project-workers PSA (Personal-Service-Agenturen) 138 see employment law 19, 22 22 21–2, 23 manual workers 27 maternity 148–9 methodology of research 9–12 minimum wage 149 Modernising Labour Law to Meet the Challenges of the 21st Century (EC Green Paper) 193–7 multilaterality in employment relationship 50–52 mutuality of obligation test 49, 70 National Employment Policies 229 normalisation with parity see equal treatment without parity 6, 8, 229 notice periods 21 outsourcing 45–7 parasubordinati part-time work 92–4 contracts definition 123–4 European Community (EC) 173 Directive 122–3, 127–8, 188, 209 flexibility 129–30 pensions 125–6 regulation 105–10, 121–6 special rights 121–31, 126–31 training 128–9 Partnership for a New Organisation of Work (EC Green Paper) 212–13 pensions 177–8 European Community 181 part-time work 125–6 personal contract of employment 82 personal performance of work 33–4 qualitative exclusions from employee status 59–68 quality of work 215 quantitative exclusions from employee status 68–71 quasi-subordination 71–81, 160–61 United Kingdom 78–80 security 226 see also job security self-employed workers 66, 151, 153–4, 159–60 European Community 175–6, 182 servant, definition 31 Smuraglia proposal 75 social security 177–8 staff-leasing 140–41 statutory intervention in employment law 63–8 sub-contracting 47 subordination 27–8, 29–30, 60–63 see also quasi-subordination attenuated 63 France 60 functional 30–34 Germany 60 Italy 60–61 personal 30–34 presumption of 37 substitution in employment relationship 47 teleworking 47 temporary agency work 94–105, 210 equal treatment 229 International Labour Organization (ILO) 157–61, 163–6 regulation 116–21, 136–41 training for part-time workers 128–9 transfer of undertakings 187 trilaterality in employment relationship 50–52 typification of employment Index umbrella contracts 70 unemployment 42, 148 United Kingdom contract of employment 19–21, 30, 183 unitary 26–7 dependency test 61–2 fixed-term work 91–2, 133, 134 regulation 115–16 freedom of contract 19 intermediation in employment contracts 38–9 mutuality of obligation test 49, 70, 183 part-time work 92 best practice 127 comparators 124–5 definition 123–4 payments 124–5 251 regulation 109–10 special rights 127–8 quasi-subordination 78–80 temporary agency work 97–104 workers 79–80 welfare states 28 work, definition 81 workbooks 22 workers 79–80, 148, 149–50, 151–4 see also agency workers; casual workers; employees; posted workers; self-employed workers European Community 172–5 free movement of 172–7 working conditions 186–91 workmen, definition 27